Greenstructure and Urban Planning - Case Study - Sheffield, UK - Historic parks and Gardens
© Anne R. Beer - 2003

Introduction

Background

Landscape

Geology and biodiversity

Planning process

Biodiversity in domestic gardens

Greenspace policies

Basic facts -

Greenstructure history

Historic gardens and parks

Woodland

Greenspace planning

Botanical gardens

Sheffield Greenspace Atlas

Statistics on Sheffield's greenspaces

Sheffield Wildlife Trust

Greenspaces of Stocksbridge District Sheffield

Greenspace Management in Stocksbridge District

Need for Greenstructure Planning in the UK

Sheffield's Historic Parks and Gardens

The following list of parks and gardens indicates all those that have so far been identified. Many are gardens in private grounds and it is very difficult if not impossible under present legislation to protect these, as the manner in which the private landowner maintains the garden is crucial to its survival. In those parts of the city which have conservation status it is at least possible to preserve most of the larger trees, if not the garden itself. It is an unfortunate fact that many of the historic gardens listed below have been and are the subject of development during this phase when the City is densifying - the result is that in the past 5 years many of the gardens have been further damaged, as new apartment blocks, school buildings or hospital buildings have been errected in their grounds.

The planning system in Britain encourages planners and councillors to protect tree cover as densification and redevelopment take place. So when any of the sites here identified as of some importance to theCity are the subject of a development proposal, it is normal for the planners to insist on layouts which preserve the major trees. This many seem at first to be an excellent solution but long-term studies by Dr. O.L. Gilbert, a Sheffield ecologist, have shown that such trees deteriorate fast and often require felling within a decade. There are instances of housing being built at present under such planning permission, which has aimed to preserve the local treescape, where all the roots on one side are disturbed and in addition because many of such sites in Sheffield are on a slope the land is also cut away below the trees - these trees have no hope of survival as healthy specimens and yet it is doubtful that the developers would have received planning permission if they had indicated from the start that the trees would be removed.

The impact of densification on the urban landscape of the area to the west of the City centre, which is recognised as of uniquely high quality in Britain and was laid out in the late 19th century, is only gradually becoming obvious. The deterioration is likely to be exacerbated by the new Government directives on density of development. These insist that residential development must be at 39 dwellings per hectare or above. In these circumstances the local authority's ability to stem the deterioration of the special local townscapes that exist within and especially to the west of the City, have been severely curtailed. The urban landscapes here are as much a result of the densely vegetated gardens as of the presence of so many large old stone buildings and the massive stone walls which line the roads - it is a privately owned and maintained landscape and greenspace which costs the City nothing and yet contributes so immensely to the image of the City as a whole.

Note: this same situation also applies to many other old gardens which are of less historic interest but nonetheless important components of the city's landscape

Figure 1 - Sheffield - diagram of the location of gardens of historic interest or with SSSi (Site of Scientific Interest) status

 

 

 

name

acquisition date

ownership

classification

suggested city heritage catagory**

national heritage category

"Weston Park"

"1875"

Sheffield City

"city_park"

most important

National register

"Firth Park"

"1875"

Sheffield City

"city_park"

most important

"Porter Valley Parks"

"1885"

Sheffield City

"city_valley_park,arc"

most important

Recommended for National register

"Norfolk Park"

"1848"

Sheffield City

"city_park"

most important

National register

"Graves Park"

"1925"

Sheffield City

"city_park"

most important

"Ecclesall Woods"

"1927"

Sheffield City

"ancient_wood,"

most important

"Whirlow Brook Park"

"1946"

Sheffield City

"city_park"

most important

"Sheffield Botanical"

"1951"

Sheffield City

"city_park"

most important

National register

"Whinfell Quarry Gard"

"1968"

Sheffield City

"city_park"

most important

Recommended for National register

"The General Cemetery"

"1977"

Sheffield City

"dist_park"

most important

Recommended for National register

"Meersbrook Park"

"1886"

Sheffield City

"dist_park"

important

"Hillsborough Park"

"1890"

Sheffield City

"dist_park"

important

"Abbeyfield Park"

"1909"

Sheffield City

"local_park"

important

"Glen Howe Park"

"1917"

Sheffield City

"dist_park_woodland"

important

"Monument Grounds- Ch"

"1929"

Sheffield City

"city_monum"

important

"Blacka Moor"

"1933"

Sheffield City

"city_openland --archaeology"

important

"Rivelin Valley"

"1934"

Sheffield City

"city_valley_park-archaeology "

important

Site of special scientific interest,IRS

"Loxley and Wadsey "

"1913"

Sheffield City

"city_openland-woods,"

important

Site of special scientific interest

"Wincobank"

Sheffield City

"dist_openland,-woods-archaeology"

important archaeology

"Beauchief Gardens"

"1935"

Sheffield City

"hist_gdn"

"historic_public_garden"

"Chelsea Park"

"1925"

Sheffield City

"hist_park"

"hist_pub_park"

"Ashdell House"

private

"hist_gdn"

"hist_private_garden"

"Barnes Hall"

private

"hist_gdn"

"19th C parkland "

"Beauchief Hall"

Sheffield City

"17th C parkland, historic garden"

"4,Cavendish Rd"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Clifford House"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Cooke & Beard Homes"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Crewe Flats, Oakholm"

University

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Dore Moor House"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"John Eaton's Almshouse"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Elmwood"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"The Glen"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Middlewood Hosp."

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

Site of special scientific interest

"Moorwinstow"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Mylnhurst School"

school

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Notre Dame School"

school

"hist gdn"

"historic garden"

"Oakes Park"

private

"hist_park"

"historic garden"

"Parkhead Hall"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Queens Tower"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Shrewsbury Hospital"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Springleigh"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Kenwood House"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Tapton Court"

University

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Thornbury Hospital"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"The Towers"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Whirlow Court"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Woodland View Almsho"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

"Woolfindin Almshouse"

private

"hist_gdn"

"historic garden"

** Note this category has no planning status and is only a subjective assessment by researchers as to the relative merits .

This list is not complete or in any way adopted by the City for planning purposes. It is only intended to indicate the main sites that should be considered as plans progress - it has no official status. The City initiated the research project in the mid 1990s and the detailed data with regard to all the sites is held in the department with responsibility for parks and greenspace. Several of the sites identified as of historic interest have since been built over as the city responds to the government's policies on densification and developers demands.

The Sheffield Botanical Gardens (constructed 1834-36) and Norfolk Heritage Park (handed to the city in 1845 are the two oldest major parks in Sheffield - they have both undergone extensive restoration in recent years with the aid of funds from the National Lottery Scheme and very large sums raised locally.

Additional information about some other Sheffield historic places with gardens

Beauchief Abbey

This is the rermains of a 12th century Abbey. It is set in charming, secluded surroundings within the City boundary. Built into the tower is a lovely 17th century chapel which is sure to delight!

Upper Chapel - Norfolk Street

Beautiful Unitarian chapel dating back 300 years, right in the heart of the City centre. The stained glass windows by pre-Raphaelite artist, Henry Holiday, are of international importance. The small tranquil Sanctuary Gardens are the perfect place for a peaceful break in the City centre. Stop and admire the bronze statues by Sheffield sculptor, George Fullard.

Cathedral of St Peter and St Paul

The City centre's only mediaeval building. Listed Grade 1, this working cathedral contains architecture from the 15th to the 20th century, housing magnificent Tudor memorials and striking stained glass. Its old graveyard is now open to the public and has become a focal point greenspace within the City centre.

 

 

Birley Spa

Birley Spa is a hidden historic and architectural gem in a tiny secluded ravine. It is the only remaining Victorian Spa in the north of England.

 

Abbeydale Industrial Hamlet

An authentic 18th century scythe works with waterwheels and tilt hammers. The house, workshops, crucible steel furnace, water wheels, machinery and dam create a charming and unique atmosphere of what life was once like. And the dam above it creates a green oasis.

Introduction

Background

Landscape

Geology and biodiversity

Planning process

Biodiversity in domestic gardens

Greenspace policies

Basic facts -

Greenstructure history

Historic gardens and parks

Woodland

Greenspace planning

Botanical gardens

Sheffield Greenspace Atlas

Statistics on Sheffield's greenspaces

Sheffield Wildlife Trust

Greenspaces of Stocksbridge District Sheffield

Greenspace Management in Stocksbridge District

Need for Greenstructure Planning in the UK

All photographs are © Anne R. Beer, 2003 but users are free to download and use as they wish, with the proviso that the copyright is always acknowledged. Students may use the text as they wish provided they again acknowledge the sources of the text.

To view the Case Studies of other cities click here Further information about some cities is available by clicking here